Open Theism is Really Not Logical, Of Course
Thursday, May 29th, 2008So he’s back on that pedestal with this sermon from Exodus. Unfortunately the recording ends before the sermon is done. Still a good listen.
And I think I should seriously say, so there is no mistake about it, because Bob seemed to think I might be swayed toward Open Theism, I really believe that Open Theism is heretical. I don’t say that lightly. We may debate time and how it was created and where God sits in relation to it. I’m not sure I’ve read Bible passages that claim that God sits outside of time. What I’m convinced of from scripture is that God is omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent. And if you believe in a God who is not omniscient, you don’t believe in the God of the Christian scriptures.
God knows all things. Nothing is hidden from his eye. Before he formed us in the womb, he knew us. He perceives our thoughts from afar and before a word is on our tongues he knows it. He knows the numbers of the hairs on our heads, and the deceitfulness of our hearts. He ordains the days of our lives. He can say with perfect precision what will happen in the future. He does know the end from the beginning. He did know that not one of Jesus’ bones would be broken and that the guard would cast lots for his clothing. And he does know the New Jerusalem will come down.
Just take one instance–the guards casting lots for Jesus’ clothes. How could God know such a thing? He has visions of the future? But only sometimes? He sees, from the time of the fall, that a seed will come and be bruised by the serpent and will crush the serpent’s head. He sees Christ and promises Abraham that through him all nations will be blessed. He gives Moses the plans to the tabernacle, making sure that everything points to Christ, he even sees the guards casting lots for Jesus’ clothing, but he can’t see Abraham taking up the knife to kill his son before it happens?
Why not? What would make it so God can see some things but not others? Who gives God visions of the future sometimes and withholds them at other times? Either God can see what lies ahead (in our human story) or he can’t. To think that he sometimes has this ability and other times loses it, is to make him a different God from who he claims to be in Scripture.





