My friend Becky Miller posted last week on people being disappointed with God. She’s against the practice.
I am, too. I’ve heard a lot lately about yelling at God, and raising our fists at God. I don’t know if anyone has actually come out and said it’s OK to do such things, but they imply that it is, I think, when they say, “God is big enough to handle it when we yell at him.” Or when they say, “The Psalmist poured out his disappointment to God—we shouldn’t try to hide it when we’re disappointed.”
These things are true. . .they just aren’t the whole truth.
It is true that we need to be honest with ourselves and with God. If we are disappointed we should go to God. Who else can we take our hurts to? Who else can fix our sorrow? And it is true that if we take our disappointment out on God and yell at him, he is big enough to handle it—he’s in the business of being long-suffering, after all. He’s used to his piddling little creatures abusing him.
But make no mistake about it, to yell at God is to abuse Him. It is especially grievous because it heaps abuse upon the head of the perfect one who never wronged anyone, who never did evil, who only ever loved you and poured out mercy upon you. It is sin. Huge, disastrous sin.
So why do people want to encourage this yelling at God, deal? I suspect they want people not to stuff their emotions but to deal with them. I’m guessing that the wonderful Christians who encourage people to be honest with God are trying to say, “If you aren’t honest with God about your pain, he can’t fix it. If you aren’t honest about your anger you’re not getting rid of it.”
Hmmm.
But we don’t encourage people to engage in other sinful activities so they can deal with them. We don’t say to the man who wants to have an affair, “Go ahead and have the affair. You want to do it so when you don’t do it you are being dishonest.” Or, in the case of anger: My children are often angry with me, and yet, I never encourage them to yell at me.
No, we encourage the lustful man and the angry child to fight the evil temptations they have to sin.
I think we should encourage people to fight the temptation to abuse God, too. We should talk sense to them. Remind them that God is good and he doesn’t deserve to be mistreated and maligned. Remind them that they are sinful and then deserve hell and they would get hell but for the great love of God in Christ.
If we are disappointed or angry with God it is because we are sinful and small and selfish and we have not believed God. He’s told us he loves us and is for us and yet we look at circumstances in our lives and decide that God is a liar. We decide he’s being stingy and mean to us.
Kind of like Eve decided in the garden. “Hey, what’s the deal? The fruit looks good and it’s good for me. Why is God withholding this good thing?”
We suffer in this age and we decide God is treating us badly. We decide he’s withholding good from us and giving us evil. We boldly go and yell at him. “I deserve better treatment than you’ve given me.”
To yell at God is to call good evil and evil good. It’s exactly upside-down to what we should be doing. We should be praising God and yelling at ourselves.
Give thanks in all things. Pray without ceasing. In everything rejoice. Be anxious for nothing but in all things, by prayer and petition, present your requests to God, with thanksgiving.
I’m not saying we should be Stoics. We are allowed to be in pain. When we are, though, we don’t yell. We make requests with thanksgiving.
Where is the command that we yell at God? Where are we told this kind of honest spewing of our emotions is healthy for us?
Sin is never ever healthy. It is always, only destructive.