Thoughts on Mental Illness
Jun 30th, 2010 Posted in Depression, Fear Not, Suffering | 2 comments »
Before I jump into why I think drugs, even ones prescribed by doctors, can become idols, I want to give some general thoughts I have on mental illness.
I have a thought about this issue for a long time. My father, I’m told by mental health professionals, was manic depressive. My brother is diagnosed as schizophrenic/manic depressive. My mother suffered from panic attacks. I had panic attacks for years. I have other brothers and sisters who use various means to medicate themselves and cope with stress. So I have considered mental illness, and I have watched different loved ones battle mental illness with a wide array of weapons.
And here are some things I have come to believe from observing people with mental illness and from reading the Bible:
- Mental illness is not sinful, but some of our treatments of it are sinful, and in mental illness there is a built-in temptation for us to handle our pain in sinful ways.
- I believe that worry, depression, and anxiety are not sinful in their first appearance because I believe that when Jesus said his soul was in agony unto death and when he sweat blood, he was in great distress. What kind of anguish was he feeling and what kind of raw terror was trying to grip him? It was obviously worse than any of us will ever feel. To be holy and to be faced with becoming sin and losing communion with the Father is beyond anything I can comprehend. But even though our sufferings are mild comparatively, I don’t believe that when we feel great anguish we are showing a lack of faith. I don’t believe that a strong desire to step out from under the pain God puts on us is sinful. If we follow Christ and go to God in prayer, asking him to remove the cup, but preferring God’s will to our own, I don’t think anyone can accuse us of sin.
- I believe that doctors don’t really know if depression is caused by a chemical imbalance, or if it causes a chemical imbalance. The chicken or the egg? I really wonder how they know there is a chemical imbalance at all. How do they weigh the chemicals in the brain? My brother has been on drugs for 38 years now, and the dosages of his drugs are varied, depending on how he feels and how prevalent his symptoms are, not according to any tests on his brain chemicals. Three doctors prescribed strong drugs for me without doing any tests on my brain. One of them took blood and tested my bladder. One did blood tests only. The other did no tests at all. All the tests that were done came back completely normal and yet the doctors wanted me to take drugs. None tested my brain chemistry.
- I believe that exercise, petting cats, having friends tell us they love us, good music, a good diet, a good night’s sleep, a compliment from a stranger, a smile from someone you’ve helped, sex, porn, funny movies, church, prayer, reading the Bible, preaching to your soul and telling it not to be downcast, praising God, good sermons, watching the sun set over the ocean, shopping for a new toy, money in the bank, a nice car, a good book on a rainy day, candlelight, certain scents, a glass of wine, and any number of other things…have the power to change our mood for the better. Some of these things can contribute to our long-term well-being. Others of them, because they are unlawful, make people feel better short-term, but then they contribute to a long-term depression (because sinning in an attempt to feel good for a while always causes the depression to worsen).
- I believe most doctors and most of our friends, because they live in a hedonistic society, have an anti-biblical slant. Doctors will often prescribe drug therapy, talk therapy, or exercise. None of these may be wrong, but why go to them first? And we hear from people in the church, things like, “You have to learn to say, ‘No.’” Or, “If you don’t take care of yourself you can’t take care of anyone else. You have to make sure your needs are met, so you will have strength to meet the needs of others.” But the Bible says he who refreshes others will himself be refreshed and we should put the interests of others ahead of our own interests. The Bible tells us one thing and society tells us the opposite thing. (People who tell us to take care of ourselves first don’t usually mean we should make sure we take time to pray and read our Bibles before we set about our days. They usually mean we should take time for a pedicure or a bubble bath, I think.)
- I believe that there are some serious downsides to taking drugs for mental illness. Some of the drugs cause people to be lethargic, to lose their sex drives, to lose their ambition, and to lose their joy. They alter personality. And they are hard on the liver. You can’t put toxins into your body long-term and not pay a price. Long-term usage can utterly destroy a person’s ability to function normally in society. Besides the physical side-effects, if the drugs make a person numb to pain, they may be making him numb to what God wants to do in his life. So before we take drugs, I think we should try a bunch of other things first. We could get a puppy. Or take a walk on the beach every day. We might try getting eight hours of sleep and giving up the coffee. We can jog or swim or ride our bikes an hour a day. We might look for a new friend or take up a new hobby. But even better than all of those, I believe, is to look in scripture and see what God prescribes for depression, worry, and anxiety.
I’ll look at that next time.








